I am not a fan of any acid dip if used improperly or for anything it is not suited for. I've been using CLR for about four years now and the results seem to be okay. That is, if this is what you're stuck starting with anyway. The plating was nearly gone and rust had moved in.

I'd rather give someone a tool than a solution. Give them an answer and they'll always expect it. Teach them how to find the answers for themselves and they will spend a lifetime learning.
As for my mental state?
"Not User Friendly"